Rubber Roof Replacement

Rubber Roof Replacement Contractor

If your flat or low-slope roof is leaking, cracked, or nearing the end of its lifespan, a rubber roof replacement can restore protection to your home or building for decades. At Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company, we specialize in replacing aging flat roofs with high-performance EPDM rubber roofing systems designed to resist water, UV damage, and extreme Midwest weather.

Our experienced roofing team provides professional inspections, honest recommendations, and expert rubber roof installation so you can protect your property with a durable, low-maintenance roofing system.

What is a Rubber Roof?

A rubber roof is a roofing system made from EPDM (ethylene propylene diene monomer), a synthetic rubber membrane designed specifically for flat and low-slope roofs.

Rubber roofing is commonly installed on:

  • Residential flat roofs
  • Home additions
  • Garages
  • Porches
  • Commercial buildings
  • Low-slope structures

EPDM membranes create a seam-resistant waterproof barrier that protects buildings from standing water, snow, and harsh temperature changes.

    Rubber Roof Replacement

    Signs You Need a Rubber Roof Replacement

    Rubber roofs are durable, but like any roofing system they eventually wear out. If you notice any of the following signs, it may be time to replace your rubber roof.

    Common Rubber Roof Problems

    Cracks or Splitting

    Over time rubber roofing can shrink and crack due to UV exposure and temperature fluctuations.

    Persistent Roof Leaks

    Leaks around seams, flashing, or penetrations often indicate membrane failure.

    Bubbling or Blistering

    Trapped moisture can create bubbles under the membrane.

    Loose Seams

    Older glue-down seams may separate and allow water to penetrate.

    Roof age over 30 years

    Most EPDM roofs last 20–30 years, depending on installation quality and maintenance.

     

    If your roof shows these warning signs, scheduling a professional inspection can help determine whether repair or full replacement is the best option.

    Benefits of Rubber Roof Replacement

    Replacing an aging flat roof with a modern rubber roofing system offers several long-term advantages.

    Exceptional Durability

    EPDM rubber roofing can withstand:

    • Heavy snow loads
    • Standing water
    • Extreme temperature swings
    • UV radiation
    • Hail and wind exposure

      Long Lifespan

      A professionally installed rubber roof can last 25–30 years or longer with proper maintenance.

        Energy Efficiency

        Rubber roofing membranes reflect heat and help stabilize indoor temperatures, which may reduce energy costs.

          Low Maintenance

          Unlike many roofing materials, EPDM membranes require minimal upkeep and can often be repaired easily if damaged.

            Seamless Waterproof Protection

            Rubber roofing systems create a watertight barrier that protects against one of the biggest threats to flat roofs: standing water infiltration.

              Smart Roofing Standards

              Our Rubber Roof
              Replacement Process

              Instant Estimate

              Click on ‘Instant Estimate’ to quickly get an initial quote and input your project description.

              Initial Contact

              Your appointed advisor will reach out to schedule your free inspection and consultation.

              Free Inspection

              Our trained experts will assess your rubber roof’s condition, then provide a detailed report of findings.

              Estimate

              After the inspection, we’ll present a comprehensive, no-obligation estimate tailored to your needs.

              Follow-Up

              We follow up to answer any additional questions and confirm your decision after your due diligence.

              Project Approval

              Once you approve the estimate, we’ll schedule the project and provide a timeline for completion.

              Preparation

              We prepare the site, ensuring safety and minimal disruption to your property.

              Installation

              Our team completes the rubber roofing work with structural integrity, full adherence, fastened and waterproofed.

              Quality Check

              After installation, we conduct a thorough quality check to ensure everything meets our Smart Standards.

              Cleanup

              We leave your property clean and tidy, removing all debris and ensuring your satisfaction.

              Final Walkthrough

              Together we will walk through our 35 point inspection addressing questions or concerns for complete satisfaction.

              Post Completion

              Long after your roof is complete, we’re always here to help and support you to maintain and protect your investment.

              Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal

              Our Commitment to Quality & Customer Satisfaction

              Smart Choice. Smart Service. Smart Roofing.

              Smart Roofing is a trusted name in southeastern Wisconsin, delivering top-quality roofing for homes and businesses. We offer competitive pricing, expert craftsmanship, and hands-on project management. With a BBB A+ rating and multiple service awards, our reputation speaks for itself. Whether it’s a home, rental, or commercial property, Dale and the team have you covered.

              Rubber Roof Replacement

              Rubber Roof Replacement vs Repair

              Many homeowners ask whether they should repair or replace their rubber roof.

              Repair May Be Possible If:

              • The roof is under 20 years old
              • Damage is limited to a small area
              • Seams or flashing need resealing

              Replacement Is Usually Recommended If:

              • The roof is over 30 years old
              • Multiple leaks are present
              • The membrane is shrinking or cracking
              • Previous repairs have failed

              A professional inspection will determine the most cost-effective solution.

              Why Choose Smart Roofing for
              Garage Roof Replacement?

              Choosing the right roofing contractor matters. Your garage roof should be installed with attention to the details that protect your building from moisture and weather. 

              Homeowners choose Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company for:

              • A longstanding local presence: Serving the community since 1950.
              • Local experience: Based in New Berlin, Wisconsin, serving the greater Milwaukee area.
              • Quality roofing products: We install roofing systems from established manufacturers, with product selection based on project requirements.
              • Thorough roof replacement practices: Removing existing roofing when specified allows the underlying deck to be inspected.
              • Personalized service: We work with homeowners to understand their roofing concerns and replacement needs.
              • Warranty options: Available manufacturer and workmanship warranty coverage depends on the products, installation, and terms of the project.

              Our goal is to provide a garage roof replacement that suits your building, protects your property, and delivers lasting value.

              Want your roof installation added to our schedule?  Start with your free estimate. 

              Schedule Your Free
              Rubber Roof Replacement Inspection

              If your flat roof is leaking or showing signs of wear, replacing the rubber membrane now can prevent costly structural damage later.

              Contact Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company today to schedule a free rubber roof inspection and replacement estimate.

              Our team will evaluate your roof, explain your options, and provide a clear plan to restore your building’s protection.

              Our goal is simple:  install a rubber roof that protects your property for decades.

              Rubber Roof Replacement FAQs

              How Long Does a Rubber Roof Replacement Take?

              Most residential rubber roof replacements take 1–2 days, depending on:

              • Roof size
              • Roof accessibility
              • Weather conditions
              • Structural repairs needed

              Larger or more complex roofs may require additional time.

              How Much Does Rubber Roof Replacement Cost?

              The cost of replacing a rubber roof depends on several factors:

              • Roof size
              • Roof accessibility
              • Insulation requirements
              • Flashing and edge details
              • Deck repairs

              Most rubber roof replacements range between $8 – $15 per square foot depending on the complexity of the project.

              The best way to get an accurate price is with a professional roof inspection and estimate.

              How long does a rubber roof last?

              Most EPDM rubber roofs last 20 to 30 years when professionally installed and properly maintained.

              Can a rubber roof be installed over an existing roof?

              In some cases yes, but it depends on local building codes and the condition of the current roof system.

              Is rubber roofing good for residential homes?

              Yes. Rubber roofing is one of the best solutions for flat and low-slope residential roofs because it provides durable waterproof protection.

              Does rubber roofing require maintenance?

              Rubber roofs require minimal maintenance, but periodic inspections help catch small issues before they become major problems.

              Who should I call for rubber roof replacement near New Berlin?

              Homeowners can contact Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company at (414) 529-9549 to discuss rubber roof replacement and request information about their project.

              Our goal is simple:  install a rubber roof that protects your property for decades.

              WHY HOMEOWNERS CHOOSE SMART ROOFING?

              At Smart Roofing, we focus on delivering direct benefits that property owners will appreciate:

              1

              Price Match Gaurantee

              If you find a better price with the services and materials we offer, let us know, and we will match it like-and-kind! But expect we’re giving you honest pricing upfront!

              2

              Decades of Experience

              With over 75 years of service in southeastern Wisconsin, we are a trusted, family-owned and operating roofing company that’s seen it all.

              3

              Honest & Local Service

              We remove the existing roof and inspect for hidden issues like wood decking damage, ventilation, and moisture concerns.

              4

              Expert Installation

              Our team consists of highly trained and certified professionals, ensuring superior craftsmanship and long-lasting results.

              Certainteed
              malarkey

              We work with the best brands

              Experiences From Smart Roofing Clients
              Posted on Google Google
              Ruud Lenssen profile picture
              Ruud Lenssen
              Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
              We had a small leak in our sunroom and called the guys at Smart roofing for a quote on a potential repair/replacement. Joey came over to the house and after a thorough inspection said that he could replace the poorly installed old flashing but, it would cause damage to the siding of the house. He recommended a temporary repair to stop the leak and advised to have it permanently fixed when we replace the siding in the near future. He fixed it right away on the spot! What a class act! Old school service and genuinely wanted to help, not just make a quick buck. Great job, Joey!!
              Posted on Google Google
              Ryan Siegler profile picture
              Ryan Siegler
              Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
              Outstanding experience! I needed a roofing quote after another company I contacted for a siding estimate told me that I also needed a new roof. Joey came out, thoroughly inspected everything, and informed me that my roof was actually in good working order. He took the time to address all of my concerns and never tried to sell me something I didn’t need. If you’re looking for an honest quote from a trustworthy company—with reviews that back up their performance—this is the place to go. When the time does come for a new roof, they’ll be the first company I call. Thanks again, Joey! Highly recommend!
              Posted on Google Google
              William Cray profile picture
              William Cray
              Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
              Dale at smart roofing is awesome! He inspected the roof on a property we were looking to buy and was really knowledgeable. While doing that inspection, I told him we had a small amount of water coming in our current home and he came right over to take a look. All the other roofers we had were complete sales guys just trying to sell us a new roof for 30k+. Dale said some simple repairs would suffice and to save the $. He's working up an estimate for us. It felt like he was advising and consulting us rather than just trying to suck as much money out of us as possible like the 2 other companies we had come look at our roof. Not to mention, when he was here he said he's pretty sure he figured out why the water was coming in and just put a handful of screws in and some caulk around a vent. He did it on the spot and didn't charge us. Just a really down to earth good guy.
              Posted on Google Google
              Ashley Kline profile picture
              Ashley Kline
              Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
              I am writing to share my appreciation for the excellent service we received recently. We had some flashing leaking on our chimney, and Dale went above and beyond to come to our house in an extremely timely manner. He went up on the roof, identified the exact problem, and fixed it immediately. Unlike the other contractors we had over, there was no guesswork involved. Smart Roofing will be handling all of our roofing needs from now on. I highly recommend their services to everyone.
              Posted on Google Google
              Charlie k profile picture
              Charlie k
              Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
              I had a roof leak I couldn’t track down. Joe came out to take a look and had a tech come right over to solve the problem. Has been dry ever since!
              Posted on Google Google
              Gabby Bergeron profile picture
              Gabby Bergeron
              Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
              Very responsive team, came to check our leaking skylight the same day when we contacted them late on a Friday, and Dale and team returned Sunday to start repairing the problem. Knowledgeable and helpful team and answered all our questions on other areas we were concerned with! Would absolutely recommend!
              Posted on Google Google
              Scott Morrell profile picture
              Scott Morrell
              Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
              We discovered water damage on our ceiling, we were understandably concerned. Our roof had been installed six years ago, but the original roofing company was no longer in business, so we had no way to have the warranty honored. After seeing this company’s outstanding Google reviews, we decided to give them a call—and they absolutely lived up to their reputation. Dale returned our call within an hour and came to our home the very same day. He was honest, knowledgeable, and never pressured us. He took the time to explain the issue, gave us several options, and even shared ways we could potentially fix it ourselves. Since we’re much more comfortable staying on the ground than climbing onto a roof, we asked Dale to handle the repair. His pricing was more than fair and an incredible value. He completed the work the very next day and provided before-and-after photos so we could see exactly what had been repaired. It’s rare to find a company that genuinely makes you feel like they’re looking out for your best interests instead of trying to maximize the bill. We were so impressed with the quality of the service, honesty, responsiveness, and workmanship that we plan to use them again for some upcoming gutter work. We highly recommend this company to anyone looking for reliable, trustworthy, and reasonably priced roofing services!
              Posted on Google Google
              david mastopietro profile picture
              david mastopietro
              Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
              They came and gave me an estimate for a roof repair yesterday. They finished up the job today and did a great job. Price was more than fair and nice people.
              Posted on Google Google
              Ross Whiting profile picture
              Ross Whiting
              Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
              Dale and his crew are very dedicated to their work. They pay attention to detail and have an excellent work ethic. They made sure everything was cleaned up before leaving each day. Great communication - they kept us informed throughout the project. Highly recommend!
              Verified by Trustindex
              Trustindex verified badge is the Universal Symbol of Trust. Only the greatest companies can get the verified badge who has a review score above 4.5, based on customer reviews over the past 12 months. Read more

              Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Standards

              What To Consider When Choosing a Rubber Roofing Contractor

              When selecting a roofing contractor, homeowners should consider several key factors to ensure a successful project:

              Licensing and Insurance

              Always choose a licensed and insured contractor to protect yourself from liability and ensure compliance with local building codes.

              Local Reputation and Reviews

              Research customer reviews and ask for references to gauge the contractor’s reliability and quality of work.

              Detailed Written Estimate

              A reputable contractor will provide a detailed written estimate outlining the scope of work, materials, and costs involved.

              Warranty and Service

              Ensure the contractor offers a solid warranty and stands behind their work with excellent customer service.

              Get A Rubber Roof Replacement Estimate

              If you’re considering a rubber roof replacement or maybe you know your ready, trust Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company to deliver outstanding results. Take the next step today by getting your free estimate followed by a Smart Roofing consultation.